There is a great RcppArmadillo
multivariate normal densities. But I was looking for the first derivative of
the multivariate normal densities. Good implementations are surprisingly hard
to come by. I wasn’t able to find any online and my first R implementations
were pretty slow. RcppArmadillo might be a great alternative particularly
because I am not aware of any c or Fortran implementations in R. In these
areas, we can expect the largest performance gains. Indeed, the RcppArmadillo
version is over 400-times faster than the R implementation!
First, let’s take a look at the density function
as shown in the The Matrix Cookbook (Nov 15, 2012 version) formula 346 and 347
where and are d-dimensional and is a variance-covariance matrix.
Now we can start with a R implementation of the first derivative of the multivariate normal distribution. First, let’s load some R packages:
Here are two implementations. One is pure R and one is based on dmvnorm in the mvtnorm package.
These implementations work but they are not very fast. So let’s look at a RcppArmadillo version.
The Mahalanobis function and the first part of dmvnorm_deriv_arma are based on this
gallery example, which implements a fast multivariate normal density with RcppArmadillo.
Now we can compare the different implementations using simulated data.
test replications elapsed relative
1 dmvnorm_deriv_arma(X, m, s) 10 0.021 1.000
3 dmvnorm_deriv2(X, mean = m, sigma = s) 10 6.813 324.429
2 dmvnorm_deriv1(X, mu = m, sigma = s) 10 22.439 1068.524
The RcppArmadillo implementation is several hundred times faster! Such stunning performance increases are possible when existing implementation rely on pure R (or, as in dmvnorm_deriv2, do some of the heavy lifting in R). Of course, the R implementation can probably be improved.
Finally, let’s plot the x- and y- derivates of the 2-dimensional normal density function.
Note: This is an updated version dated 2015-01-06 of the original article.